Cosets and Lagrange's Theorem

A rigorous treatment of cosets, Lagrange's theorem, and their fundamental consequences for the structure of finite groups

Cosets and Lagrange's Theorem#

The theory of cosets provides the key to understanding how subgroups sit inside groups. When we partition a group by a subgroup, we obtain a collection of "translates" called cosets, each having the same size as the subgroup. This simple observation leads to one of the most important theorems in finite group theory: Lagrange's theorem, which asserts that the order of a subgroup must divide the order of the group.

Lagrange's theorem, though elementary in its statement and proof, has profound consequences. It immediately implies that the order of any element divides the order of the group, provides necessary conditions for the existence of subgroups, and underlies much of the deeper structure theory of groups.

Cosets#

Let HH be a subgroup of a group GG. We wish to understand how HH partitions GG into disjoint pieces.

Definition2.1.1(Left Coset)

Let HH be a subgroup of a group GG and let aGa \in G. The left coset of HH containing aa is the set

aH={ah:hH}aH = \{ah : h \in H\}

The element aa is called a representative of the coset aHaH.

Definition2.1.2(Right Coset)

Similarly, the right coset of HH containing aa is the set

Ha={ha:hH}Ha = \{ha : h \in H\}
Remark

In general, left cosets and right cosets are different. However, when the group operation is written additively (as in abelian groups), we write a+H={a+h:hH}a + H = \{a + h : h \in H\}, and left and right cosets coincide.

Example2.1.3(Cosets in the Integers)

Consider the subgroup

3Z={,6,3,0,3,6,}3\mathbb{Z} = \{\ldots, -6, -3, 0, 3, 6, \ldots\}

of (Z,+)(\mathbb{Z}, +). The cosets of 3Z3\mathbb{Z} are:

0+3Z=3Z={,6,3,0,3,6,}0 + 3\mathbb{Z} = 3\mathbb{Z} = \{\ldots, -6, -3, 0, 3, 6, \ldots\} 1+3Z={,5,2,1,4,7,}1 + 3\mathbb{Z} = \{\ldots, -5, -2, 1, 4, 7, \ldots\} 2+3Z={,4,1,2,5,8,}2 + 3\mathbb{Z} = \{\ldots, -4, -1, 2, 5, 8, \ldots\}

These three cosets partition Z\mathbb{Z}, and each coset corresponds to a residue class modulo 33.

Example2.1.4(Cosets in S3S_3)

Let G=S3G = S_3 and let H={e,(12)}H = \{e, (12)\}, a subgroup of order 22. The left cosets of HH are:

eH={e,(12)}=HeH = \{e, (12)\} = H (12)H={(12),e}=H(12)H = \{(12), e\} = H (13)H={(13),(132)}(13)H = \{(13), (132)\} (23)H={(23),(123)}(23)H = \{(23), (123)\} (123)H={(123),(23)}(123)H = \{(123), (23)\} (132)H={(132),(13)}(132)H = \{(132), (13)\}

Thus there are exactly three distinct left cosets: HH, (13)H(13)H, and (23)H(23)H.

The following theorem establishes the fundamental properties of cosets.

Theorem2.1.5(Properties of Cosets)

Let HH be a subgroup of a group GG and let a,bGa, b \in G. Then:

  1. aaHa \in aH
  2. aH=HaH = H if and only if aHa \in H
  3. aH=bHaH = bH if and only if a1bHa^{-1}b \in H
  4. aH=bHaH = bH or aHbH=aH \cap bH = \emptyset
  5. aH=H|aH| = |H|
  6. The distinct left cosets of HH partition GG
Corollary2.1.6

Two left cosets aHaH and bHbH are equal if and only if b1aHb^{-1}a \in H.

Definition2.1.7(Index)

Let HH be a subgroup of a group GG. The index of HH in GG, denoted [G:H][G:H], is the number of distinct left cosets of HH in GG.

Remark

The index [G:H][G:H] may be finite or infinite. When GG is finite, the index is always finite. When GG is infinite, the index may be finite (as with [Z:nZ]=n[\mathbb{Z} : n\mathbb{Z}] = n) or infinite.

Lagrange's Theorem#

We now prove the fundamental theorem relating the orders of a group and its subgroups.

Theorem2.2.1(Lagrange's Theorem)

Let GG be a finite group and let HH be a subgroup of GG. Then H|H| divides G|G|. More precisely:

G=H[G:H]|G| = |H| \cdot [G:H]
Remark

The theorem is named after Joseph-Louis Lagrange (1736–1813), who proved a version of this result for permutation groups in 1770–1771, predating the abstract definition of a group by several decades.

Example2.2.2

In S3S_3, we have S3=6|S_3| = 6. The possible orders of subgroups are the divisors of 66: namely 1,2,3,61, 2, 3, 6. Indeed:

  • Order 11: the trivial subgroup {e}\{e\}
  • Order 22: {e,(12)}\{e, (12)\}, {e,(13)}\{e, (13)\}, {e,(23)}\{e, (23)\}
  • Order 33: {e,(123),(132)}=A3\{e, (123), (132)\} = A_3
  • Order 66: S3S_3 itself
Remark

The converse of Lagrange's theorem is false in general: if dd divides G|G|, there need not exist a subgroup of order dd. The smallest counterexample is the alternating group A4A_4 of order 1212, which has no subgroup of order 66.

Consequences of Lagrange's Theorem#

Lagrange's theorem has numerous important corollaries.

Corollary2.3.1(Order of an Element Divides Group Order)

Let GG be a finite group and let aGa \in G. Then the order of aa divides G|G|.

Corollary2.3.2

Let GG be a finite group and let aGa \in G. Then aG=ea^{|G|} = e.

Corollary2.3.3(Groups of Prime Order)

Let GG be a group of prime order pp. Then GG is cyclic, and every non-identity element is a generator.

Corollary2.3.4(Fermat's Little Theorem)

Let pp be a prime and let aa be an integer not divisible by pp. Then:

ap11(modp)a^{p-1} \equiv 1 \pmod{p}
Corollary2.3.5(Euler's Theorem)

Let nn be a positive integer and let aa be an integer with gcd(a,n)=1\gcd(a, n) = 1. Then:

aϕ(n)1(modn)a^{\phi(n)} \equiv 1 \pmod{n}

where ϕ(n)\phi(n) is Euler's totient function.

The Index and Subgroup Chains#

The index satisfies a multiplicative property for chains of subgroups.

Theorem2.4.1(Tower Law)

Let KHGK \leq H \leq G be groups. Then:

[G:K]=[G:H][H:K][G:K] = [G:H] \cdot [H:K]

In particular, if any two of the three indices are finite, so is the third.

Corollary2.4.2

If HH and KK are subgroups of a finite group GG with KHK \leq H, then [G:K][G:K] is divisible by both [G:H][G:H] and [H:K][H:K].

Cosets and the Symmetric Group#

We apply coset theory to analyze the structure of symmetric groups.

Definition2.5.1(Alternating Group)

A permutation σSn\sigma \in S_n is called even if it can be written as a product of an even number of transpositions, and odd if it can be written as a product of an odd number of transpositions. The alternating group AnA_n is the set of all even permutations in SnS_n.

Theorem2.5.2

The alternating group AnA_n is a subgroup of SnS_n of index 22. Consequently:

An=n!2|A_n| = \frac{n!}{2}
Example2.5.3

In S3S_3:

  • Even permutations: ee, (123)(123), (132)(132)
  • Odd permutations: (12)(12), (13)(13), (23)(23)

Thus A3={e,(123),(132)}A_3 = \{e, (123), (132)\} has order 33.

Example2.5.4

The group A4A_4 has order 1212. Its elements are:

  • The identity ee
  • The eight 33-cycles: (123),(132),(124),(142),(134),(143),(234),(243)(123), (132), (124), (142), (134), (143), (234), (243)
  • The three products of disjoint transpositions: (12)(34),(13)(24),(14)(23)(12)(34), (13)(24), (14)(23)

Chapter Review#

Question 1 of 5

If H is a subgroup of G and a ∈ G, what is the left coset aH?

Practice Problems#

Key Equations#

Lagrange's Theorem
G=H[G:H]|G| = |H| \cdot [G:H]
Tower Law
[G:K]=[G:H][H:K][G:K] = [G:H] \cdot [H:K]
Euler's Theorem
aϕ(n)1(modn)a^{\phi(n)} \equiv 1 \pmod{n}
Continues to

Normal Subgroups

Application

Quotient Groups

Application

Modular Arithmetic